The Loch Ness Monster

For over 1,500 years, something has been seen in the dark waters of Scotland’s most mysterious loch. From a 6th-century saint’s encounter to modern sonar contacts, the Loch Ness Monster—affectionately known as “Nessie”—remains the world’s most famous cryptid. Despite dozens of expeditions, thousands of sightings, and the march of technology, the creature of Loch Ness stubbornly refuses to reveal itself—or to disappear.

Loch Ness: The Setting

Scotland’s Great Glen

Loch Ness lies in the Scottish Highlands, running along the Great Glen fault line that slices diagonally across Scotland. The loch is part of the Caledonian Canal system connecting the North Sea to the Atlantic.

The Statistics:

• Length: 23 miles (37 km)
• Maximum width: 1.5 miles (2.3 km)
• Maximum depth: 755 feet (230 m)
• Surface area: 21.8 square miles (56 km²)
• Volume: More water than all the lakes in England and Wales combined

The Perfect Hiding Place

Loch Ness is ideally suited for harboring a mystery:

Visibility: The water is stained dark brown by peat from surrounding highlands. Visibility is typically only 10-15 feet (3-5 meters). Below the surface, it’s like swimming in weak tea.

Depth: The loch is deeper than the North Sea at most points. Its bottom features underwater caves, ledges, and tunnels that have never been fully explored.

Temperature: The water temperature remains a nearly constant 42°F (5.5°C) year-round at depth—cold enough to preserve organic matter and prevent bodies from rising (due to suppressed decomposition gases).

Connection to the Sea: The River Ness connects the loch to the Moray Firth and the North Sea, providing a potential route for marine creatures to enter.

The Ancient Origins

Saint Columba (565 AD)

The earliest written account of a monster in the waters around Loch Ness appears in the Life of Saint Columba, written by Adomnán around 700 AD—approximately 140 years after the events described.

According to the account, in 565 AD, the Irish missionary Saint Columba was traveling through the Scottish Highlands when he came upon local Picts burying a man who had been bitten and killed by a water beast while swimming in the River Ness.

Columba ordered one of his followers, Luigne moccu Min, to swim across the river to retrieve a boat. As Luigne swam, the beast rose from the depths, “with a great roar and open mouth.”

Columba raised his hand, made the sign of the cross, and commanded:

“Go no further. Do not touch the man. Go back at once.”

The creature allegedly fled “as if pulled back with ropes,” terrified by the saint’s voice. The Picts, witnessing this miracle, converted to Christianity.

Interpreting the Account

Believers point to this as the first documented Nessie sighting—evidence that something has inhabited these waters for at least 1,500 years.

Skeptics note that:

• Water-beast stories were common in medieval hagiographies (saints’ biographies)
• The account was written over a century after the supposed event
• The story follows a standard “saint defeats monster” template found in many cultures
• The location was the River Ness, not the loch itself

The Modern Era (1933-Present)

The Road That Changed Everything

For centuries, Loch Ness was isolated—accessible only by boat or difficult overland routes. Sightings, if they occurred, went largely unrecorded.

That changed in 1933, when a new road (the A82) was completed along the northern shore, offering unobstructed views of the loch to automobile travelers for the first time.

On May 2, 1933, the Inverness Courier published a story that would spark a worldwide sensation.

The Mackay Sighting

John and Aldie Mackay, a local couple driving along the new road, reported seeing a tremendous disturbance in the normally calm waters. Mrs. Mackay described seeing “the beast” rolling and plunging for a full minute before diving.

The newspaper account used the word “monster”—and the legend was born.

The Spicer Sighting

On July 22, 1933, George Spicer and his wife were driving along the southern shore when they saw a bizarre creature crossing the road ahead of them:

• About 4 feet high and 25 feet long
• Moved in jerky, caterpillar-like motions
• Had a long, undulating neck
• Carried something in its mouth (possibly an animal)
• Disappeared into the undergrowth toward the loch

This sighting of a land-crossing creature added a dramatic new dimension to the mystery.

The Floodgates Open

Following these reports, sightings multiplied:

• Hundreds of people reported seeing humps, heads, and wakes
• Letters flooded newspapers
• Monster hunters descended on the loch
• The Daily Mail sponsored the first major expedition

By the end of 1933, “Nessie” had become an international celebrity.

The Surgeon’s Photograph (1934)

The Most Famous Monster Photo

On April 21, 1934, the Daily Mail published what would become the most iconic monster photograph in history.

The image, reportedly taken by Dr. Robert Kenneth Wilson, a London surgeon, appeared to show a small head and long neck rising from the water. Wilson claimed he had simply been visiting the loch and happened to have his camera ready.

The “Surgeon’s Photograph” became:

• The definitive Nessie image
• Reproduced millions of times worldwide
• “Proof” for believers
• The template for all future Nessie depictions

For sixty years, the photograph remained the gold standard of monster evidence.

The Confession (1994)

In 1994, the truth finally emerged.

Shortly before his death, Christian Spurling confessed that the photograph was an elaborate hoax masterminded by his stepfather, Marmaduke Wetherell.

The backstory:

• Wetherell was a big-game hunter hired by the Daily Mail in 1933 to find the monster
• He discovered “monster footprints” that were later revealed to be made with a hippopotamus foot umbrella stand
• Humiliated by the exposure, Wetherell sought revenge on the newspaper
• His son Ian and stepson Christian built a toy submarine with a sculpted monster head attached
• They photographed it at the loch and gave the photo to the unsuspecting Dr. Wilson to maintain credibility

The full, uncropped photograph—rarely seen—reveals that the “monster” was only about 2-3 feet (60-90 cm) long.

The Aftermath

Despite the exposure, the photograph had done its work. For sixty years, it had fixed in the public mind the image of Nessie as a plesiosaur-like creature. Even today, that image persists.

And curiously, the hoax hasn’t stopped the sightings.

Major Evidence and Expeditions

Tim Dinsdale Film (1960)

Tim Dinsdale, an aeronautical engineer, filmed something moving across Loch Ness on April 23, 1960. The footage shows a hump-like object moving steadily through the water for several minutes before submerging.

The film was analyzed by:

• The Royal Air Force Joint Air Reconnaissance Intelligence Centre (JARIC)
• Concluded it showed “probably an animate object”
• Estimated the object at 12-16 feet long
• Ruled out boats, debris, or known animals

Skeptics suggest it may have been a boat, with the wash creating the illusion of a humped creature.

Robert Rines Expeditions (1972-1975)

Robert Rines, a patent attorney and inventor, conducted multiple expeditions using underwater cameras and sonar.

In 1972, his team captured a photograph showing what appeared to be a large flipper—diamond-shaped and approximately 6-8 feet long.

In 1975, additional photographs appeared to show:

• A long-necked body
• A “gargoyle-like” head

Rines declared these images proof of a large unknown animal and proposed the scientific name Nessiteras rhombopteryx (“Ness monster with diamond-shaped fin”).

Critics noted that the images were heavily enhanced, and alternative analysts saw only ambiguous shapes. An anagram hunter pointed out that “Nessiteras rhombopteryx” rearranges to spell “Monster hoax by Sir Peter S”—a reference to naturalist Sir Peter Scott, who had helped name the creature.

Operation Deepscan (1987)

The largest sonar search ever conducted at Loch Ness involved:

• 24 boats with sonar equipment
• Sweeping the entire loch simultaneously
• Multiple days of operation

Results:

• Three sonar contacts detected objects larger than any known fish
• The objects moved and evaded the sonar curtain
• Could not be identified or explained

Skeptics suggested the contacts might have been:

• Schools of fish
• Underwater debris
• Sonar artifacts

The operation proved neither that monsters existed nor that they didn’t.

The 2019 DNA Study

A team led by Professor Neil Gemmell of New Zealand’s University of Otago conducted the most comprehensive environmental DNA (eDNA) study of Loch Ness ever attempted.

Method: Collect water samples from throughout the loch, extract and analyze all DNA present.

Findings:

• No DNA from large unknown animals
• No reptile DNA (ruling out plesiosaurs)
• No shark or sturgeon DNA
• Significant amounts of eel DNA

Conclusion: If there is a large creature in Loch Ness, the most likely candidate is a giant eel.

Gemmell stated he “could not rule out” the possibility of unusually large eels, though none were directly observed. The traditional Nessie—a prehistoric plesiosaur—was effectively ruled out.

What Could Nessie Be?

Theories

Plesiosaur Survivor: The traditional theory: a population of prehistoric marine reptiles survived extinction and lives in Loch Ness.

Problems:

• Plesiosaurs were air-breathing; they would surface frequently
• The loch is only 10,000 years old (post-Ice Age)
• A breeding population would require many individuals
• No DNA evidence
• The 2019 study found no reptile DNA

Giant Eel: The most scientifically plausible explanation. European eels can grow to 6 feet; a mutation or unique conditions might produce much larger specimens.

Support:

• Significant eel DNA in the loch
• Eels can explain the “long neck” shape
• Known to inhabit Loch Ness
• Serpentine movement matches some descriptions

Sturgeon: Atlantic sturgeon can reach 12+ feet and have a prehistoric appearance. They occasionally enter fresh water.

Problems:

• No sturgeon DNA found
• Sturgeon don’t match the “humped” descriptions

Misidentification: Many sightings may be:

• Boat wakes
• Floating logs
• Swimming deer or other animals
• Optical illusions
• Wave patterns

Hoaxes: Some sightings (like the Surgeon’s Photograph) are deliberate fakes. Tourism benefits from the legend.

Genuine Unknown: A small population of unknown large animals—possibly a species science hasn’t catalogued—inhabits the deep, dark waters.

Recent Sightings

Sightings Continue

Despite the scientific consensus that Nessie (as traditionally conceived) doesn’t exist, sightings continue:

• The Official Loch Ness Monster Sightings Register documents new reports every year
• Cameras and drones capture unexplained shapes
• Tourists and locals alike report unusual disturbances

2023: The 90th anniversary of the 1933 sightings prompted a massive coordinated search using:

• Thermal imaging drones
• Hydrophones
• An underwater robot
• Hundreds of volunteers

Results:

• Detected some unusual sounds (later attributed to ducks)
• No definitive evidence of large creatures
• Public interest remained high

The Economic Monster

Whatever Nessie may or may not be, she is very real economically:

• One million visitors annually
• Tourism revenue of approximately $80 million per year
• Hotels, tours, museums, and gift shops
• An entire regional economy built on the legend

The monster is worth more as a mystery than a solution.

Loch Ness Today

Visiting the Loch

The Loch Ness area offers:

• Urquhart Castle — ruins overlooking the loch with excellent viewing
• The Loch Ness Centre — museum documenting the legend
• Boat tours — cruises with sonar equipment
• The Official Loch Ness Monster Exhibition
• Hiking trails along the shores

Best viewing points include:

• Castle Urquhart
• Dores Beach
• Fort Augustus
• The A82 layby near Invermoriston

The Ongoing Mystery

After 90 years of modern investigation and 1,500 years of reported sightings, Loch Ness keeps its secrets.

The dark water hides whatever lies beneath. Technology advances, but so does the monster’s ability to evade detection. Each search generates publicity—but no proof.

Perhaps that’s the point. Some mysteries are more valuable unsolved. Nessie has become:

• A symbol of the unknown
• A reminder that nature may still hide surprises
• A tourist attraction
• A beloved cultural icon

Monster or myth, plesiosaur or eel, Nessie has earned her place in human imagination.

---

For over a thousand years, something has been glimpsed in Loch Ness. Science says it’s probably not there. The sightings say otherwise. And in those dark waters, 755 feet deep and too murky to see, Nessie keeps us guessing—as she always has.